What is the difference between a pulsed radar and a continuous wave radar at millimeter wave frequencies?
Pulsed vs CW Radar
At mmWave frequencies, FMCW is the overwhelmingly dominant radar architecture for commercial and automotive applications due to its simplicity, low cost, and excellent resolution performance.
- Performance verification: confirm specifications against the application requirements before finalizing the design
- Environmental factors: temperature range, humidity, and vibration affect long-term reliability and parameter drift
- Cost vs. performance: evaluate whether the application demands premium components or standard commercial grades
- Interface compatibility: verify impedance, connector type, and mechanical form factor match the system architecture
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is FMCW dominant at mmWave?
Three reasons: (1) Integration: the entire FMCW radar (VCO, PLL, PA, LNA, mixer, ADC, DSP) fits on a single SiGe or CMOS IC. The low TX power (< +15 dBm) allows the PA to be integrated. A pulsed radar needs a separate high-power PA and a fast T/R switch, making single-chip integration impractical. (2) Resolution from bandwidth: at mmWave, wide bandwidth is available (4-14 GHz). FMCW directly converts this bandwidth to range resolution. No need for ultrashort pulses. (3) Cost: the single-chip FMCW IC costs $5-$15 at volume. A comparable pulsed radar at 77 GHz would cost 10-100× more. For automotive and consumer markets: cost is the decisive factor.
Can FMCW radar measure velocity?
Yes. FMCW radar measures velocity through the Doppler shift observed across multiple chirps. Within a single chirp: only range is measured (from the beat frequency). Across multiple chirps: the phase of the beat signal changes proportionally to the target velocity (Δφ = 4πv·T_chirp/λ). A Doppler FFT across N chirps resolves the velocity. This is the standard "Range-Doppler" processing used in all modern FMCW radar. Velocity resolution: Δv = λ/(2·N·T_chirp). For N = 128 at T_chirp = 50 μs at 77 GHz: Δv = 0.30 m/s. Max unambiguous velocity: v_max = λ/(4·T_chirp) = 12.5 m/s (for T_chirp = 78 μs).
What about noise radar?
Noise radar transmits a random noise waveform (instead of a chirp or pulse). Range is measured by correlating the received signal with a delayed copy of the transmitted noise. Advantages: inherently low probability of intercept (LPI); the transmitted signal looks like noise. No interference with other radars (the noise is unique). Disadvantages: lower processing gain than FMCW (the correlation is less efficient than matched filtering of a deterministic chirp). More complex signal processing. Used in: military LPI radar, through-wall radar, and some research applications. At mmWave: noise radar is a niche technology. FMCW dominates due to lower cost and higher performance.