How does the insertion loss of a switch affect the overall system noise figure?
Switch Loss and Noise Figure
The placement and insertion loss of RF switches is a critical receiver design decision because every tenth of a dB of pre-LNA loss directly degrades the receiver sensitivity.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much NF degradation is acceptable from the switch?
The acceptable NF degradation depends on the overall NF budget and sensitivity requirement: for radio astronomy (system NF < 0.5 dB): switch IL must be < 0.1 dB (use MEMS or place switch after the cryogenic LNA). For satellite ground station (NF < 1.5 dB): switch IL < 0.3 dB (use low-loss FET or MEMS). For cellular base station (NF < 3 dB): switch IL < 0.5 dB (standard FET switches suffice). For handset (NF < 7 dB): switch IL < 0.5 dB (SOI CMOS standard). For test equipment (NF not critical): switch IL < 2 dB is acceptable. Rule of thumb: the switch should contribute < 10% of the total system NF budget. If total NF = 3 dB: switch can contribute < 0.3 dB.
Does an SP8T switch have more loss than an SPDT?
Yes, but the increase depends on the architecture: (1) Series-shunt topology (each throw has a series FET in the signal path): IL is approximately the same regardless of the number of throws (the signal only passes through one series FET). But: the parallel OFF-state capacitances of the other throws load the common port, increasing the effective capacitance and slightly increasing IL. For an SP8T: IL ≈ SPDT IL + 0.1-0.3 dB (due to the loading from 7 OFF-state throws). (2) Distributed tree topology (cascade of SPDT switches): an SP8T = 3 stages of SPDT. IL = 3 × SPDT IL. If SPDT = 0.3 dB: SP8T = 0.9 dB. This is why monolithic SP8T switches (single-stage) are preferred over cascaded SPDT trees (the single-stage has lower total IL).
Can I compensate for switch loss with more LNA gain?
Not directly. Adding more LNA gain after the switch does not reduce the NF (the NF is determined by the first components in the chain). More gain improves the signal level at downstream stages but does not reduce the noise already added by the switch and LNA. However: you can reduce the NF impact of the switch by adding a low-noise amplifier BEFORE the switch (between the antenna and the switch). This pre-switch LNA amplifies the signal before the switch loss is introduced. The NF contribution of the switch becomes: delta_NF = IL_sw / G_pre_LNA. For G_pre_LNA = 15 dB and IL_sw = 0.5 dB: delta_NF = 0.5/31.6 = 0.016 dB (negligible). Trade-off: the pre-switch LNA must handle the full antenna bandwidth (all bands), increasing susceptibility to out-of-band interferers. This architecture is used in military and SDR receivers where ultimate sensitivity is needed.